Welcome, Guest
Username Password: Remember me

Profile for nicholas6225

  • OFFLINE
  • Rank: Senior Boarder
  • Register Date: 07 Feb 2013
  • Last Visit Date: 19 May 2013
  • Time Zone: GMT -5:00
  • Local Time: 20:32
  • Posts: 53
  • Profile Views: 123
  • Karma: 8
  • Location: Canada
  • Gender: Male
  • Birthdate: Unknown

Signature

Posts

Posts

emo
This thread is a wonderful example of the attention to detail and the professionalism of the owners, employees, and the loyal wicked edge users who make owning a wicked edge knife sharpener a happy community. Cheers for the comments, and pay it forward to the next batch of rookies who flood in to purchase WEPS or accessories in the future and get frustrated when they don't get their toys immediately.
The way I see it is the more hype and popularity the WEPS gets, the better the sharpener will be, the more accessories become available, and more information will be available on the forum, which makes us all a better knife sharpener:)
Got a couple of new Kershaw's yesterday and the factory edge isn't up to my standard so i'm off to smoke a fatty and continue to break in my new ceramic stones:)
Nick
Ordered Pro-Pack 1 a ...
Category: Suggestion Box
emo
BillWood wrote:
Well fella's, I'm having a different problem with checking the hair whittling edge on my knifes. For the past 10 years I have been shaving my head and the wife is getting tired of me sneaking up behind her and snatching a couple of hairs from her head. I'll have to stop that for a while or my arm will be too sore to sharpen any knives. She said she would cut off a few but lets face it, it's just not as fun that way.


lol, less painful way, just take the hairs off her hairbrush, I usually brush or comb my hair to acquire a hair, it's less painful that way
Need help with techn ...
emo
wcbwx34 wrote:
johpe wrote:
I've also read in various posts by other people (amongst them Clay) that it can be recommended to back off 1-2 degrees when stropping with leather strops to avoid rounding the edge. (So if you sharpen at 20 degrees, then when switching to stropping with leather, you change the angle to 21 or 22 degrees.)


This is actually backwards... Clay lowers the angle 1 or 2 degrees... so he would drop to 18-19 from a 20 deg. angle.

That being said, while I have tried this, I still get a better edge raising the angle to strop... even though it contradicts the microscope photos Clay has posted... and my own attempts at stropping at a lower angle. (So use what works for you).

I think pressure is a big culprit (at all levels, but especially the finishing stones and strops), that's probably what I'd look at first.

All the suggestions so far are good. Ken has a point... you might try testing your edge before you strop, and see what it's like.


This is great info.
I use each and every suggestion that's been posted on this thread.
Here is my technique
1.Consistency is key
2.use light even pressure
3.remove burr often (I use a balsa stick which i run along the edge)
4.take your time and pay attention

I managed to use diamond stones 1000 grit, balsa 14&10 paste and leather 5&3.5 paste strops to get a hair whittling edge. I do the same thing as you but I also create a large burr at 1000 grit on both sides, removing burrs with balsa stick and then continue to work both sides at 1000 grit using very, very light pressure. I clean the burr again with the balsa stick gently a couple times. I then switch to my 14&10um balsa strops and after a few strokes I test the edge at several points with a hair, at this point some places are hair whittling. From there I feel the edge by constantly test the edge with a hair and strop with balsa till the entire edge is hair whittling before moving to the leather strops.

I just received micro fine ceramics and nano cloth strops with 1&.25um sprays but have not yet been able to get a hair whittling edge, but I know its because the ceramics are still new and being worked in. It should be possible to get a hair whittling edge on the ceramics in the near future though.

Its a great feeling to get a knife that sharp, have fun dude.
Nick
Need help with techn ...
emo
Worth a try for sure. I don't for see any issues. In my own stropping kit I reserved 14/10 micron paste for balsa, 5/3.5 paste for leather, and 1/0.25 spray on nano cloth. I really like my balsa strops and the edge I'm able to get with them, totally worthwhile.
What paste/spray to ...
Category: Stropping
emo
Great to hear, I also attempted to input a few knives a week or so ago with no result and was wondering if I should just attempt to re-add them, now i know.
thanks Mark.
Knife does not show ...
Category: Off Topic
emo
I have a 30x loop and regret not getting one with a light. I also like having a microscope, i use a Veho 400x but it can be tricky at times and a little frustrating to get pictures but I love the detail I do get to see.
Jeweler's Loupe
emo
PhilipPasteur wrote:
Hey Chris,
As to knife steels, there is a huge amount of information online. Use you favorite search engine. I don't know of one place that I could send you that covers it all.
Here are a few that I have read, but there are many more.

www.knifeart.com/steelfaqbyjo.html


www.cliffstamp.com/knives/reviews/blade_materials.html

www.simplytoolsteel.com/knife-steel-comparison-chart.html

Also both Bladeforums.com and Knifeforums.com have extensive discussions about blade steel.
Go to either site and search on the name of the steel you want to know about. I have not yet dones that and not found a great deal of information.


If you know a type of steel you can find its composition and compare it to other steels here:

zknives.com/knives/steels/steelgraph.php

The you probably want to know about heat treating and hardening.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_treating

www.roymech.co.uk/Useful_Tables/Matter/Hardening.html

www.primitiveways.com/Steel%20heat%20treatment.html

www.asminternational.org/content/ASM/StoreFiles/ACF180B.pdf

Now these are just a few that I have bookmarked. There is a huge amount of information out there. There have been volumes written on the subject and the study of steels and their behavior and properties is a field of study and an entire science unto itself. You could also visit your local library and find a wealth of information on this field of study.

In other words, you just need to dig and spend some time, there are far more than a couple of good resouces, and no single source that I know of is complete.


AWESOME!!!!! you are my idol Phil!!!!!!
It Just Keeps Gettin ...
Category: Welcome Mat
emo
WayneAnderson wrote:
I guess my biggest concern would be the billing of the credit card for the full amount, but no product is shipped. I am not a fan of this practice. If someone at WE could shed some light on this topic I would like to hear from them. Until then I will sit on the side line and wait to see how Stephens' issue is delt with.

Wayne...


I understand, but instead of waiting why not check out the place Ken Schwartz's works, they seem to have quite a bit of stuff in stock, i'm contemplating purchasing the water stones to avoid the wait but then I need to suck up the custom fees:( There are a few places that have the WEPS in stock, you just need to look around
Ordered Pro-Pack 1 a ...
Category: Suggestion Box
emo
coryschnaufer wrote:
Stephen and Wayne,

Here is my experience with the wicked edge crew. I ordered my wicked edge about two years ago when it was on a one month back order. After one month I got notice that there was some issues with quality control and it would be another month. At this point iwas aggravated but what can you do but grin and bare it? So at sixty days I got another notice that it was going to be another month and I lost it. I wrote to both Kay, and Clay to express my displeasure. The bottom line was they weren't going to put outa product that they were not 100% satisfied with. They were having some issues with the factory at the time and were behind on many orders but they were taking all of the abuse put forth by who knows how many people so that the product was perfect! Remember even though the company has been around a few years it is still basically a small family owned and operated business that is trying to keep up with a rapidly growing demand. Anyway I waited my 90 days and got my sharpener and have neve regretted the waiter the purchase. Perfection may take a while but when it finally gets here it is always well worth the wait! Trust me when I say that Clay and crew are busting there butts to get it out as fast as they can and with the best quality possible!


Very well put!!!!

Patience guys, it sucks having to wait but the guys at the wicked edge wont screw you. There are a lot of these stories on the internet and they seem to be popping up more and more.... ever wonder why?? the wicked edge is blowing up and gaining popularity and the reason they are growing is because they don't put out a shitty product. I live in canada and getting the wicked edge and accessories can be tedious at times, so i understand your frustration, and I reassure you they have never screwed me or sent me a shitty product. In another five years there might be WEPS kits in every department store but if we want to have the most current toys right now, there are sacrifices we all have to make.

Anyways, i'm positive one of the wicked edge employees or clay himself will see this post and respond. My .02
Ordered Pro-Pack 1 a ...
Category: Suggestion Box
emo
My "tricks" for getting and keeping a hair whittling edge is consistency. I cook for a living and the knives i'm referring to are for that purpose. They take a beating during everyday use, but they are cared for and respected as extensions of my hand. I track detailed accounts of my sharpening in terms of mounting settings, angle degree, grit progression, lowest grit ever used, and 400x pictures of the heel, belly, and tip of each knife before and after each sharpening.

When sharpening I test the sharpness of an edge after .4 micron ceramic stones with a hair at several places along the edge to determine if its hair whittling from there I progress to 14um balsa where I stay till the entire edge is hair whittling sharp from heel to tip from left side to ride side. Then I progress to leather, nano cloth strops to .25 micron. I determine when to change grits using a microscope, making sure the scratch patterns are consistent and testing the edge with a hair.

Then on a daily basis with general use I strop my knives on a blank leather strop or blank balsa strop at work depending on the condition of the knife. I have a two sided free hand strop that I've made which has cow leather on one side and balsa wood on the other side (basically a fine and course side). I found a huge change in the quality of an edge i could maintain this way.

This works great for me, the effort I put in maintain my knives is minimum but I get the results I really don't need in a kitchen environment. lets just say a few people have cut themselves by just "looking" at my knives:P I have mirrored bevels, insane edges, and it makes work so much more enjoyable.
Hair Whittling and A ...
Category: Ultimate Sharpness
emo
PhilipPasteur wrote:
nicholas6225 wrote:
I experience dirty micro chipping on a white carbon 61-64 HRC using diamond stones, it was all my fault for apexing the edge with diamonds though. I did manage, at the time, to get a edge on that Deba using the diamond stones and finishing with balsa and leather strops, but I had to be very gentle with the diamond stones. I personally don't recommend trying to refine an edge with diamond stones on chippy steel or anything about 62 HRC IMO.


That is a bit of a generalization, and should be taken as that rather than a hard and fast rule. As just one example I have done some ZDP 189 at between (different blades) 65 to 67 Hrc. I have not yet seen or had cause to believe that there was any micro chipping caused by using all of the diamond plates from 100 through 1000.
Much depends on the steel you are talking about, probably more so than the hardness. It also is dependent on your technique. BTW, the ZDP 189 was sharpened to a burr with the 100 grit dimonds and apexed at every grit from there on up.

Possibly I did not completely understand what you were saying though. What do you mean when you say "trying to refine and edge", in the context of your statement. I guess that I wouldn't consider any edge really refined after the 1K diamonds. Granted, some folks love that edge, but refined... nope!

Phil


Hey there Phil,
Learning very quickly you are always on the ball. You're right... It was a very vague and generalized comment that i made, allow me to clarify my comment. I was referring to my experience with white carbon (aka aogami 1 (just for you Phil the composition of white carbon steel C 1.25-1.35; W 1.50-2.00; CR 0.30-0.50; Mn 0.20-0.30; P 0.025; S 0.004; Si 0.10-0.20)) I've also found a vague breakdown of ZDP 189 (C 3.00; W 1.50; V 0.10; Cr 20.00; Mo 1.30; Mn?; P?; S?; Si? Not trying to give anyone a chemistry lesson but Phil is right when he said it depends on the type of steel verse the HRC rating. As I am learning you can have the exact same knife from the same brand but the hardness could be 1-3 points different because of the slightly different heat treatments. The main reason I found White steel super chippy was the low amount of chromium that adds toughness to a steel and not having vanadium added at all. Don't get me wrong the persistence of tungsten is what helps white carbon from being so brittle after heat treating but it can only do so much. The other issue with my example is the knife in question is a hand made knife where a blacksmith in some little dark hole with a fire burning is gauging the temperature of the steel by color or experience, which leaves a lot of room for error. The ZDP 189 you offered is a powder super steel that is usually only used in a "lab" production setting where everything is controlled with precision (hence the reason those knives are usually stupid expensive).

In terms of using diamond stones on "hard" steels I still don't support it. I don't see the point of taking a Ferrari for a drive on a snowy day, but hey if you got it and want to its all yours. Like I said I was able to polish and get an edge on the knife using diamond stones, anything is possible with determination and your right it involved a lot of changes in my technique and how i was sharpening. What I meant by "Refined" was an apexed edge free of chips and fractures, uniform at the apex in my case at 400x magnification. I really guess the term refined means something different to everyone, I am working on getting the japanese water stones this year so I can also understand what you mean by "refined." Have you had a chance to see the apexed edge of your zdp 189 under big magnification at various grits? i'd be interested to see pictures.

I hope this helps clear some stuff up Phil, I hope I don't come off as standoffish. Not my intention:(
It Just Keeps Gettin ...
Category: Welcome Mat
emo
I experience dirty micro chipping on a white carbon 61-64 HRC using diamond stones, it was all my fault for apexing the edge with diamonds though. I did manage, at the time, to get a edge on that Deba using the diamond stones and finishing with balsa and leather strops, but I had to be very gentle with the diamond stones. I personally don't recommend trying to refine an edge with diamond stones on chippy steel or anything about 62 HRC IMO.
It Just Keeps Gettin ...
Category: Welcome Mat
emo
Hey guys,
Just received some new toys for the wicked edge. Bought micro ceramics, nano-cloth strops, 1 and .25 micron diamond sprays to add to my kit from target gallery in Edmonton, Alberta, Canada. Spoke to Guy on Tuesday and received my goodies on Thursday, I now have two days to touch up my blades with my new toys:) I'm waiting on the water stones to arrive in Canada so I can complete my wicked edge and start purchasing pure white and blue carbon carbon steel 63-67 HRC knives. Anyways, big thanks to the boys at Target Gallery
p.s wicked edge please send a shipment of the japanese water stones to Canada
New wicked edge toys ...
Category: Off Topic
emo
you should try it on your knee and see if its dependent on the bone. Which can possibly translate into an answer to a question I asked recently "what are the benefits of aluminium or glass strop backings?"
Diamond stones on th ...
emo
Hey guys,

Question about the possible mounting options for strops. what are the individual benefits of either aluminium or glass to back nano or kangaroo products to the wicked edge handles? Is glass mainly better because of the consistency in flatness?
Aluminium or glass b ...
Category: Stropping
emo
wickededge wrote:
Just checked out your photos and spreadsheet - totally awesome! Thank you for sharing it. Have you added those knives to the database?


Not yet, just fine tuning everything before I share my mounting specs, but as soon as I do they'll be share
Nice setup... like how you're documenting your sharpening with microscope pics within your spreadsheet as you sharpen. Should make for a useful database over time.

Be careful having your computer that close though... you may want to get some magnets and put on your WE, so the metal dust doesn't get in your laptop. Just a thought.

Thanks for the info! Welcome (again)!


Thanks, I've been updating my set up hard for a couple weeks now, since that photo i've added a few rare earth magnets and a resting board for the rods. Actually, here is what my set-up looks today.

My goal this year is to acquire the japanese water stones for my collection, I am also reading a lot about the Shapton stones and was wondering if Ken is still producing them? I'm currently purchasing kitchen knives from blacksmiths in japan, i'm really getting into the the pure carbon and some of the new steels such as R2 steel. I purchased my first blue carbon 2 a month ago and have been reluctant to use it because I really don't want to use diamond on them:P I'm just patiently waiting at this point for stones

Thanks for the wonderful information guys
Hello from Canada, e ...
Category: Welcome Mat
emo
I had the same issue with a japanese white carbon steel deba. It was such a B$%#$, but it was all my fault for using diamond stones on a 64 rockwell knife, I should have used water stones. But who knows white carbon is a super chippy steel.
Blade chipping probl ...
emo
Hey there wicked edge forum,

I kind of do things backwards, so after spending a few months on this forum i'm finally writing on the welcome mat

I'm joining you guys from Canada, my name is Nicholas, I purchased my WEPS Pro pack 1 and a few accessories last year in June from target gallery's in Edmonton, Alberta. The owner, Guy, was a pleasure to deal with. We had to correspond via e-mail and he was more then helpful. Pretty sure its the only WEPS retailer in Canada now I spent months debating on spending the money on this and i'm so happy I did. Guy made it possible to purchase and have the base shipped for a decent price. He also was able to provide options in terms of ceramics, stropping options, and compounds.

Since purchasing my WEPS I've learned a lot about sharpening and realized that there is so much more information out there to learn. My technique has changed multiple times since that first experience with the WEPS, most recently my techniques have evolved mainly because of information available on this forum. This is one of the best places to learn about knife sharpening and different techniques associated with knife sharpening.

Anyways, cheers to the wicked edge team for putting out a great product out and providing a place where people are free to share their opinions and thoughts about your product and anything else.

Here you can see my current set-up

and the beginning of an OCD sharpening monster in the making, my excel speadsheet attached
[attachment:1]C:\fakepath\WEPS Knife Log.xlsx[/attachment]

if that doesn't work you can check it outHere

Well thats me,

Cheers
Hello from Canada, e ...
Category: Welcome Mat
emo
Great job, I really like the idea of the slots for the poles with and without stones. My only question is how do you like having the board on the front of the wicked edge verse the back? do you find yourself resting your arms against it when sharpening?

I'm taking my wood board off right now and creating grooves also
WE mod that save som ...
emo
R.JeffreyCoates wrote:
Here is an explanation that I ran across:

The principle advantage to an asymmetrical edge is allowing the knife to take a steeper angle while leaving enough steel behind the edge to support the acute geometry. If you want to achieve the same grind angles on a double bevel, the bevels are going to be much larger and go up the side of the knife quite a bit. It'll be a thinner edge so chipping/rolling becomes an issue; though japanese knives usually chip with the high RHc.

It made sense to me.


It does make sense to me as well. If you think about what would happen if you of put a very acute 30 to 10 degrees inclusive edge on a western steel knife with a RHC of say 55-58, the steel would be too soft and constantly roll over on when used. you can either have a ferrari for a knife that you need to always be careful with or you can have a honda civic for a knife that you can make crazy sharp every once in a while. I can deal with the chippy blades, they do need more care but man, having a razor blade for a month working in a kitchen makes them really special.

cheers
ASYMETRICAL SHARPENI ...
More
Time to create page: 1.71 seconds